By default SDL will only enumerate controllers, to reduce risk of hanging or crashing on devices with bad drivers and avoiding macOS keyboard capture permission prompts.
The hidapi method of storing the error on the device is not thread-safe, and not only could it result in a double free if multiple threads were setting the error at the same time, but SDL could be trying to use the error message and have it be freed out from under it by another thread.
Use SDL's error functions since they already use thread-local storage.
This reverts commit 2b386b6c80.
This isn't the right approach. Even if the string itself isn't double-freed, it can be returned to the application and then freed while the application is trying to use it. This really needs to be in thread-local storage to be completely safe.
In SDL we already have a global thread-local error string, so I'm going to make an SDL-specific change to handle the error strings safely.
The error string is not protected by a mutex, and can be set from multiple threads at the same time. Without this change, it can be double-freed. It can still be double-allocated, leading to a memory leak, but at least it won't crash now.
Signed-off-by: Sam Lantinga <slouken@libsdl.org>
Touching HID devices with keyboard usages will trigger a keyboard capture
permission prompt on macOS 11+. See #4887
Like the IOKit joystick backend, we accept HID devices that have joystick,
gamepad, or multi-axis controller usages. We also allow the Valve VID for
the Steam Controller, just like the Windows HIDAPI implementation does.
Signed-off-by: Cameron Gutman <aicommander@gmail.com>
Signed-off-by: Sam Lantinga <slouken@libsdl.org>
c1b9d2ad98
Properly handle the close of run loop on macOS
(https://github.com/libusb/hidapi/pull/522)
- as per documentation `kCFRunLoopRunStopped` should be handled once the runloop is closed via `CFRunLoopStop`;
- if it is not handled - a race condition/crash may happen on the latest macOS when a device gets disconnected while being open;
I ran this script in the include directory:
```sh
sed -i '' -e 's,#include "\(SDL.*\)",#include <SDL3/\1>,' *.h
```
I ran this script in the src directory:
```sh
for i in ../include/SDL3/SDL*.h
do hdr=$(basename $i)
if [ x"$(echo $hdr | egrep 'SDL_main|SDL_name|SDL_test|SDL_syswm|SDL_opengl|SDL_egl|SDL_vulkan')" != x ]; then
find . -type f -exec sed -i '' -e 's,#include "\('$hdr'\)",#include <SDL3/\1>,' {} \;
else
find . -type f -exec sed -i '' -e '/#include "'$hdr'"/d' {} \;
fi
done
```
Fixes https://github.com/libsdl-org/SDL/issues/6575
This prevents a number of issues where devices are enumerated but not actually able to be opened, like https://github.com/libsdl-org/SDL/issues/5781.
We currently leave the devices open, allowing us to more easily do controller feature detection, protocol negotiation, detect dropped Bluetooth connections, etc. with the expectation that the application is likely to open the controllers shortly.
Unfortunately the only way to detect this is to actually try opening a device, so we wait until the application tries, and then stop enumerating afterwards.
Fixes https://github.com/libsdl-org/SDL/issues/5781
Touching HID devices with keyboard usages will trigger a keyboard capture
permission prompt on macOS 11+. See #4887
Like the IOKit joystick backend, we accept HID devices that have joystick,
gamepad, or multi-axis controller usages. We also allow the Valve VID for
the Steam Controller, just like the Windows HIDAPI implementation does.
This prevents conflicts with hidapi linked with applications, as well as allowing applications to make use of HIDAPI on Android and other platforms that might not normally have an implementation available.
Sam Lantinga
Ozkan Sezer
Ryan C. Gordon
Anonymous Maarten
Pierre Wendling
Cameron Gutman
Patrick Hogan